There is a lot of book packed into the pages of this work. Truth Considered & Applied: Examining Postmodernism, History, and Christian Faith is by Stewart E. Kelly, who is a philosophy professor at Minot State University (in North Dakota) and the author of several books. This book is published by B&H Publishing Group.
The website says that it is for philosophy and theology students. I agree, but would add that it is valuable for history teachers and students as well (referring to college level history majors).
Here is a bit of my experience with this book. Back in the fall, I found a stack of copies of this book at a religious bookstore. Most Christian bookstores don’t have too many titles that are brainy or philosophical books. Just try this: Walk into your nice Christian bookstore and ask for books by Dooyeweerd, Kuyper, Van Til, Gordon Clark, Rushdoony, James K. A. Smith, or Christopher Dawson. (Byron Borger’s Heart and Mind Books is an exception. There are others.) But this store had this book on truth and postmodernism in abundance.
I went back to my office to look up this “new” title. To my surprise, I learned that this book had been out since 2011. And no customer reviews were posted on Amazon. (I am changing that.) I soon acquired the book, but it has taken a while to work my way through it. The slow pace was due to the many books I am trying to read, as well as the challenging nature of this book.
For those who want an enjoyable and anecdotal survey of some modern ideas, look elsewhere. This book has the feel of being a professor’s expanded outline notes. It has a mountain of bibliographical and footnoted information. It is a walk through the section of the library dealing with modern thought with glances through the writings of key thinkers. It will overwhelm you (in a good way) with the books, terms, ideas, and names which have contributed to modern thought and postmodern thought.
The pastor counseling a couple with a few marriage problems or the history teacher with a classroom full of eighth graders will not find answers here. But I really hope that pastors and history teachers have the time and inclination to get outside of their boxes and explore these issues. There are connections between the ramblings of brilliant, but misdirected philosophers and the cultural and social problems that we face in everyday life. As I once told Richard Weaver, “You know, Richard, that all of these ideas I am teaching you have consequences.” (Don’t fact check that story!)
For beginners and novices, like me, this book is a good survey or introduction to lots of issues. Well chosen quotes begin each section. The quotes alone are good glimpses of some of the ideas that have been bouncing back and forth between intellectuals, philosophers, theologians, and academics. I would love to take a class, preferably with Dr. Kelly teaching it, where we were reading and discussing this book.
The first 152 pages of this book are on postmodernism itself. It is titled “Friend or Foe: The Challenge of Postmodernism.” The next section, titled “Truth and History,” is much more my area of interest. In that part, Kelly covers the ways that historians have interpreted history over the past hundred years or so. Sometimes we may wonder why a person would read four different books on the same topic or era of history. Certainly, the facts don’t change. But history books have never been and can never be about listing facts. Even the encyclopedia is selective and interpretive about what facts to include.
Schools of thought and methods of interpretation change. With two major world wars and the rise and fall of various ideologies, the histories of the twentieth century are going to reflect both the time they were written and the school of thought of the authors. This may not change the way that I hope to finish my discussion of Gettysburg next Monday in history class, but it does affect my historical understanding at other levels.
There are people who like hamburgers. That’s fine. But some people have to go beyond the culinary delight of two all beef patties on a sesame seed bun to understanding the cattle industry, wheat production, vegetable harvests, and food distribution. Likewise, some people like history. May their tribes increase. Whether it is good biographies, the History Channel, historical fiction, or touring Civil War battlefields, all such interest is good. But some of us really need to understand the inner workings of the discipline. This book will help.
In short, some of you really need to get this book and study it. Pick up on the recurring names and ideas. Let this book be a launching pad for deeper and further studies.
Post Script: Dr. Kelly devotes about two pages of small print in an extended footnote listing authors and titles of history works that have influenced his understanding of “postmodern historiography and historical epistemology.” As one who has been around the library and history block a few times, I am astounded at the range of books he calls attention to. The journey never ends.