The Heavy Laden Bookshelf should fire me as it chief book reviewer. Problem is that that would involve me firing myself, and I don’t know who I could hire who would work as cheaply as I do. But I am far too slow as a reader. And I ain’t too swuft at getting reviews completed. So, it looks like I am stuck with keeping me as my chief book reviewer.
Let’s look at some of the history backlog for a moment. The nine standing books in the picture above have all been glanced over or started, but none are finished yet.
Editor to Reviewer: Say something about the standing books.
Reviewer to Editor: Well, I have finished and written reviews on the two that are lying down (Sand & Steel and Apostle to the East).
Editor to Reviewer: There are nine books you have to get going. Get some reviews completed. At the very least, say something about them.
Reviewer to Editor: Okay, I’ll try, Sir.
So here goes:
Earlier in the summer, I read Rick Atkinson’s delightful The British are Coming. I always wish that I were more focused and maybe even totally absorbed in reading about the American War for Independence. The problem is that I harbor the same wish about another two dozen historical eras and I flit from historical branch to branch and never settle in.
General Charles Cornwallis is often relegated to a bit part in American history, and it is the role of a loser. The name of Cornwallis is associated with Yorktown, defeat of the British, “The World Turned Upside Down,” and a number of other images that all spell out the word LOSER. Of course, history could have easily turned in a different direction, but what if’s, while fun, are simply speculations.
The southern venture by the British Army seemed to have all the making of a success. The possibility of rallying the southern colonies back to the British side, of rooting out the rebellion to the south, and succeeding in the classic “divide and conquer” strategy could have and maybe should have worked.
Cornwallis blazed a trail of Pyrrhic victories across the Carolinas and into Virginia. Then matters only got worse as Cornwallis’s luck or fortune ran out. Let’s go ahead and use the word they used then: Providence gave the upper hand to the Patriot army and their French allies.
Very promising book.
My review copy of this book, which came out last May, included information about the author tour promoting this work. Sad to report, Mr. Horwitz died just a few weeks after this book came out.
I had looked into one of Horwitz’s earlier books, Confederates in the Attic, and when my teacher Dr. Thomas Curtrer called my attention this book, I was immediately interested. This book is a retelling of one story with a newer accompanying story. The original story was that of Frederick Law Omsted, a journalist and architect (1822-1903), who traveled across the southern states in the years before the War Between the States. His writings were combined into a volume titled Journeys and Explorations into the Cotton Kingdom, which was published in 1861.
Horwitz studied Omsted’s work and then began retracing his traveling. By that, I mean that he ventured on a journey to the same places and updated us on the life, communities, and cultures across the way.
This is a very readable and enjoyable book. Unfortunately for me, I keep letting it get lost in the dangerously high reading stacks beside my bed. It is good, easy-going, and entertaining reading that can handily precede sleep.
Travel books were, perhaps, more popular in past centuries. Writers such as Charles Dickens and Mark Twain were masters of such writings. In our day, it is easy enough to either travel ourselves, or to watch documentaries, or to Google places across the land and become familiar with them.
But getting the feel of the culture is a more complicated matter. The questions that I suppose this book raises are “What was the South like when Omsted traveled and observed it?” and “What has changed?” Putting this book back to the top to read. Thankful that the author was able to finish it.
Leaders: Myth and Reality by General Stanley McChrystal, Jeff Eggers, and Jason Mangone is published by Portfolio/Penguin.
Leadership comes in all varieties, areas, and styles. The subjects for this book are diverse and unexpected. The chapters cover the following people: Walt Disney, Coco Chanel, Albert Einstein, Leonard Bernstein, Maximilien Robespierre, Abu Musab Al-Zarqawi, Zheng He, Harriet Tubman, “Boss” Tweed, Margaret Thatcher, Martin Luther, and Martin Luther King, Jr.
Those who might expect leaders in a book like this to be solely political and military figures are to be a bit surprised. Part of the attractiveness of this book is its diversity of subjects and the surprising inclusions. When I started reading the book, I was astounded by the genius of Walt Disney. On the one hand, I am not a big fan of Disney productions–past and present. On the other hand, one cannot read about the man without marveling at his creative genius and drive. Coco Chanel was another surprise. I began with having no clear idea who she was, and then made the connection with the women’s perfume Chanel #5. Coco Chanel was a creator and marketer of fragrances. This was an enjoyable chapter. I would not want to read a lengthy book on Coco, but the picture of her skills was delightful.
I do hope to keep plowing along in this succession of accounts of various leaders and varied styles of leadership. On a downside note, I was irritated in the beginning of this book where Gen. McChrystal detailed his dislike of Gen. Robert E. Lee. He told of having put a framed portrait of Lee in the trash bin. I buy the idea that one can find fault with Lee’s leadership at many points, but this smacked a bit too much of playing to the crowd-tastes of our age.
This is yet another, Volume 66, in the amazing Campaigns and Commanders series published by Oklahoma University Press. Have I mentioned that I wish I had every single one of them?
One of the most amazing and maybe amusing facts of U. S. history is that our country waged its first two wars against the supreme naval power of the world. The fact that we came out of both wars without being vanquished is a delight, especially when talking with friends across the pond. Ton for ton and gun for gun, there is no way the fledgling American navy or lack thereof could have held its own against His Majesty’s Royal Fleets.
The subtitle explains a bit of how and why we muddled through. The smallest of boats and crews can conduct raids. Small boats, manned by daring men, can poke, jab, hit and run, and do some damage to the greatest of fleets. Like a horsefly plaguing a stallion, the ability to sting here and there can be effective.
This is the story of such efforts. Dr. Alexander is Assistant Professor of War Studies and Naval History at the U. S. Naval Academy.
Thunder and Flames: Americans in the Crucible of Conflict, 1917-1918 by Edward G. Lengel is published by the University Press of Kansas.
I first became acquainted with the writings of Ed Lengel last fall when I was on a World War I binge. I was teaching about the Twentieth Century and came across his recently published book Never in Finer Company: The Men of the Great War’s Lost Battalion. My review of that enjoyable book is found HERE.
This book came out in 2015, so it precedes Never in Finer Company and also tells the story of the bigger picture of the American involvement in World War I. As I often mention, the First World War is so overshadowed by the Second World War that we forget how awful, long, and hard fought it was. American involvement can be oversimplified in two ways. First, the war starts in 1914, and then the U. S. enters in 1917 and more directly in 1918 and finishes up the mess that Europe had started. A second way is to view the American contribution as a minor thing. The German army was a spent force by the time the U. S. arrived, and the main work had been accomplished by the French and British.
History always lends itself to easy explanations until the digging begins.
Ed Lengel is quite an amazing historian. He wrote several books on George Washington, and then he published three or four studies of America in World War I. Next year, he will have a new book coming out on the Revolutionary War. Recently installed as the Senior Director of Programs at the National World War II Museum in New Orleans, he will probably whip out a few books on that war.
I will need to highlight these books a bit later. I have too many books even to briefly describe.
Rosebud June 17, 1876: Prelude to the Little Big Horn by Paul L. Hedren is published by the University of Oklahoma Press.
Political Hell-Raiser: The Life and Times of Burton K. Wheeler of Montana by Marc C. Johnson is published by Oklahoma University Press also.
Competing Memories: The Legacy of Arkansas’s Civil War, edited by Mark K. Christ, is published by the University of Arkansas Press.